second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Archive |
Posted by: Larry Becnel ® 09/05/2002, 08:57:57 Author Profile Mail author |
Dear All, I've learned so much from this board. Last week I almost came to tears (and that's not easy for me) just thinking how fortunate I've been to find this group. I felt very isolated before. I'm posting news of my treatment regime for what benefit it may have for others. Last week I received 30 units (I had mistakenly understood my Doc to say 20)in the left cord (in-office procedure). My spasming was reduced, though still pronounced. Yesterday, my Doc and I decided to inject the right cord with 30 units from the same bottle of Botox (kept frozen). On examination, he said that the left cord had smoothed out nicely but the right cord was still spasming. So we did the right cord. This morning my voice is weak, but smoother. We'll see how it goes. I have depositions next week. Larry, AD/SD, New Orleans |
| Recommend | Alert | Previous | Next | Current page |
Replies to this message |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: second injection of the week -- Larry Becnel | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Sherry A. Kjellberg ® 09/06/2002, 16:50:58 Author Profile Mail author |
Larry, Did you really mean "30" cc.s? My doc started me out on 1 cc each unit (he's fellowship trained at Johns Hopkins). He finally went up over the past few months to 3 cc.s in each chord on Wed. Today I am happily breathy and losing my old voice. I was just curious why you were getting such a huge dosage, or maybe I've misunderstood units vs. cc.s.? Sherry in Denver |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Sherry A. Kjellberg | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Larry Becnel ® 09/09/2002, 08:51:02 Author Profile Mail author |
30 units. |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: second injection of the week -- Larry Becnel | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Lynne Martinez ® 09/06/2002, 17:35:03 Author Profile Mail author |
Whoa, Larry... I'm confused. I've met people who get 10 units in each cord (20% of a 100 unit vial) and I've met people who only get only .3 units (point-three)in each cord (way, way less) and everything in between - bilaterally as well as unilaterally. But, 30 units in each cord??? Are you kidding? I've never heard of anything so high. Have you gotten a second opinion or tried another doc or is there a reason for the doseage being so high? Are you sure the doc is hitting the right muscle? Botox is not usually so inefficient as to need 60 units into the tiny vocal muscles (or is it?...am I missing something?) Good luck. This takes my breath away. Sounds more like the doseage for cervical dystonia (ST - into those big neck muscles)? --Lynne
|
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Lynne Martinez | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Larry Becnel ® 09/09/2002, 08:55:33 Author Profile Mail author |
Yes, Lynne, 30 units each side, spaced one week apart. Today, 5 days after the last injection, I basically have no voice. I do trust my doc, and he and his partner have been treating SD for years. My spasms without a high dosage are really overwhelming. We'll see if the next treatment will require so high a dosage. Thanks for your input and your concern. |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Larry Becnel | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Lynne Martinez ® 09/09/2002, 12:21:58 Author Profile Mail author |
Wow, Larry... That's all I can say. Since I never had Botox myself (as my doctor insisted on surgery based on my severe case), I can't relate to that doseage from a personal basis. But, I can't remember any SD Botox doseages on this Bulletin Board in the past years that took such a high dose. Who knows, maybe some of them should have (?); and, maybe some did but didn't put their doseage out on the BB? Sometimes I wish we (as patients who enjoy doing research to try to figure out our disorder) had a list of who is taking a certain doseage, in which cord and at which duration and from which doctor. I'm interested in all of this, having been an analyst in my past life. It's just my analytical personality. Good luck, Larry, and keep us posted. I'm not concerned at all about the doseage into your body, having sat through some Botox treatments (driving my friends with Cervical Dystonia, who couldn't drive themselves due to their twisted neck, to their appointments). --Lynne (AD/SD; Northern California) |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Larry Becnel | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Anne Brett ® 09/09/2002, 13:01:51 Author Profile Mail author |
Is your doctor using the botulinum toxin type B (known as Myobloc) or the botulinum toxin type A (known as Botox). There is a large difference in the dosage given between the Myobloc and the Botox. Most SD patients are on the Botox injections but some doctors are now using the Myobloc to see how it does on SD patients who don't respond well to the Botox (botulinum A) injections. That possibly accounts for the large unit dosage you're getting?? Anne |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Anne Brett | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Lynne Martinez ® 09/09/2002, 13:25:41 Author Profile Mail author |
Great point, Anne. Even though I've been to a couple of Myobloc seminars, I didn't think to ask Larry that question (you're so brilliant!). I just figure when people say *Botox,* they mean botulinum-Type A and *Myobloc* is botulinum-Type B. Not the same product or the same pharmaceutical company. The *mouse units* in medical testing of the botulinum products (a laboratory-term re how much it takes to have an effect), are different for each. Myobloc is still in the *Test Phase* as far as how much, in a Botox injection, corresponds to a Myobloc injection for SD patients. The doctors who inject Cervical Dystonia patients have a better handle on it as the official ("on-label" - which means FDA approval) Myobloc testing for dystonia was done with Cervical Dystonia patients. Thanks Anne. This intrigues me! Since Myobloc is so new for SD patients, I guess we'll have to go through this Botox/Myobloc translation for some time, ensuring we're not dealing with apples and oranges. --Lynne |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Lynne Martinez | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Lloyd Pearson(BC) ® 09/09/2002, 21:02:30 Author Profile Mail author |
Let's throw a banana into the pile of oranges and apples. Our friends from UK and Europe are using a product called Dysport ( equivalent to Botox type A ) but again, the unit measurements are completely different from Botox Type A. I believe they are somewhere in the region of 10 times the botox units. So it's very, very important not to generalise on the injected product - whether it be Botox, Myobloc or Dysport - all being used around the world with completely different unit measurement levels. Lloyd Pearson(BC) Canada AD/SD |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Lloyd Pearson(BC) | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Lynne Martinez ® 09/09/2002, 21:49:34 Author Profile Mail author |
Lloyd! Funny. Great fruit salad. Larry is in New Orleans so he's probably not on Dysport but this is an excellent point re being specific (fruit-salad-wise), rather than general, in our references. It reminds me that (all these years I've been on this BB) injectees haven't always been specific as to product, duration, unilateral v. bilateral, doseage, etc. I find the whole thing quite fascinating. Thanks, Lynne PS: I wrote to Renee Urban on her private e-mail so I hope she responds, re her Myobloc doseage and have you ever heard of anyone in the US or Canada taking Dysport?
|
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Lynne Martinez | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Lloyd Pearson(BC) ® 09/10/2002, 19:02:59 Author Profile Mail author |
Lynne, No I don't know of any one in North America being given Dysport. I don't think it's even available here. But the figure of about 10 units Dysport to 1 unit Botox somehow sticks in my mind. Lloyd PS - see Bill Vanderlinde's post in this thread re: ratio of approx 100 units Myobloc to 1 unit Botox |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Anne Brett | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Larry Becnel ® 09/10/2002, 13:07:13 Author Profile Mail author |
Botox. |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: second injection of the week -- Larry Becnel | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: gavin hadley ® 09/09/2002, 16:10:08 Author Profile Mail author |
Larry... Let me second Lynne's wow. I don't see how it's physically possible to inject 30 units into a tiny vocal chord; but like you say, he's the doctor. I'd be interested in knowing how long your breathy stage lasts. thx. gavin hadley |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- gavin hadley | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Lynne Martinez ® 09/09/2002, 17:21:39 Author Profile Mail author |
Hi Gavin, See Anne's post and mine back to her. Can't wait to hear back from Larry, on this issue. And, also, I'm interested in hearing from Renee Urban of this BB (who is on Myobloc) to know how much she is getting in her injections. She sounded breathy but good in Arizona, on Myobloc. Renee...respond please, re your doseage? Renee is the only SD-patient I know personally who is a Myobloc patient. Writing to Renee now in hopes she can shed some light on these doseages. --Lynne PS: There are attributes for Myobloc, over Botox (such as not having to do the "once a month-thing" since Myobloc is a stable solution) but it's very important NOT to confuse them.
|
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: BOTOX vs. Myobloc | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Lynne Martinez | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: William Vanderlinde ® 09/10/2002, 16:00:52 Author Profile Mail author |
In the notes for the Scottsdale Symposium found here: http://www.dystonia-support.org/ Dr. Adler discusses the differences between BOTOX and Myoblock in some detail. He states that 1 unit of BOTOX is roughly equal to 100 units of Myobloc. Bill Vanderlinde
|
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Lynne Martinez | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Renee Urban ® 09/15/2002, 15:38:34 Author Profile Mail author |
William Vanderlinde is correct in that the doseage requirement is 1 to 100 units going from botox to myobloc. I take 250 units of myobloc, which means that I would take 2.5 units of botox. 30 units of botox is a tremendously large amount. I hope that Larry's doctor knows what he's doing.
|
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | Next | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- Renee Urban | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Larry Becnel ® 09/18/2002, 16:36:29 Author Profile Mail author |
Renee-- Thanks for your concern. Low dosages just did me absolutely no good. My voice is still weak from the last injections, but at least I can whisper and be understood (although the telephone is still a problem). With the spasms, sometimes I couldn't get anything out. Larry |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | | Current page |
Re: second injection of the week | ![]() | ||
Re: Re: second injection of the week -- gavin hadley | Top of Thread | Archive |
Posted by: Larry Becnel ® 09/10/2002, 13:10:28 Author Profile Mail author |
Well, let's just say it felt as though the needle was in there for an eternity. |
| Recommend | Alert | Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread | Previous | | Current page |