Spasmodic Dysphonia Bulletin Board

Sentences to differentiate between ABSD and ADSD
  Archive
Posted by: sheila weston ®
09/16/2007, 03:49:49


A few years ago a circular from the (I think)NSDA included two sentences which demonstrated the differences between Adductor and Abductor SD. I believe that one contained lots of hard sounds and the other had lots of aaas and ooos.

Has anyone still got these or can make up two more? Is it abductor SD which has problems with long vowel sounds?

Sheila




| Recommend | Alert   Current page

Replies to this message

Re: Sentences to differentiate between ABSD and ADSD
Re: Sentences to differentiate between ABSD and ADSD -- sheila weston Top of thread Archive
Posted by: ktblue ®
09/17/2007, 18:54:22


There are two sentences in the archives made up of voiced and unvoiced sounds but I believe that differentiates between SD and MTD. I've never seen sentences for ABSD and ADSD but I've been at this less than a year. I'm still trying to learn as much as I can.

Good luck
Katie




| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: Sentences to differentiate between ABSD and ADSD
Re: Sentences to differentiate between ABSD and ADSD -- sheila weston Top of thread Archive
Posted by: Keith ®
09/19/2007, 19:24:04


Hi Sheila:
Sustained vowels are more difficult for those with AD than AB, since in AD the vocal folds tend to be pressed together (adducted) too tight making continuous phonation difficult. With AB, the vocal folds are too far apart (abducted), resulting in the characteristic spasmodic break or breathiness between the unvoiced consonants and the vowels that follow them. So, some sample sentences that should elicit symptoms of each form of SD would be as follows:

For AB:

1) He saw half a shape mystically cross fifty or sixty steps in front of his sister Kathy's house
2) She sells seashells by the seashore
3) The puppy bit the tape
4) Poor Harry's kite got torn in the tree

For AD:

1) Early one morning a man and a woman were ambling along a one mile lane running near rainy Island Avenue just before dawn
2) Albert eats eggs every Easter early in the a.m.
3) The bad dog won't let me get near. (not sure about this one - although it does feature words beginning with voiced consonants. I have AB - and so am much less aware of what specifically gives trouble for those with AD)


Those with AD generally have more difficulty with words starting with voiced consonants, such as b, d, g, l, m, n, etc. AB'ers have more trouble with words using unvoiced consonants prior to the vowel - f, h, k, p, s, t, sh, etc.

Hope this helps....

Regards,
Keith




| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: Sentences to differentiate between ABSD and ADSD
Re: Re: Sentences to differentiate between ABSD and ADSD -- Keith Top of thread Archive
Posted by: LoriB724 ®
09/21/2007, 14:16:52


AMAZING!! I read the first one with no problem and was thinking that it didn't work. I read the second and found out...I have AD! I never knew which one I had.

Thanks Keith :)


Lori B.




| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: Sentences to differentiate between ABSD and ADSD
Re: Re: Sentences to differentiate between ABSD and ADSD -- LoriB724 Top of thread Archive
Posted by: Keith ®
09/24/2007, 21:52:23


Hi Lori:
Wow...glad the sentences were so definitive in helping you figure out which form of SD you have. Of course, it is advisable to see an ENT to have a more thorough investigation endoscopically so that they can see exactly what your vocal folds are doing during phonation. Best of luck.

Keith




| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page