Spasmodic Dysphonia Bulletin Board

Ashley Simpson....SD???
  Archive
Posted by: Nikki ®
02/02/2005, 09:43:48


I don't know if any of you guys watch the Ashley Simpson Show, but she has recently began experiencing problems with her voice. She went to the doctor and the doctor told her that she had acid reflux (the same thing I was told in the beginning before getting my true diagnosis of SD). She began doing voice exercises. It has not gotten necessarily better. On the last episode she woke up with a raspy voice and as the day progressed, so did the raspy voice. By the end of the day, she decided that she could not perform on Saturday Night Live (live) and would have to lipsync because her voice had gotten that bad. This sounds very similar to me, in that I lost my singing voice before I lost my speaking voice. I am concerned for her because as we all know, SD is not a "popular medical condition" and a lot of physicians don't even know about it. I actually tried to go to her website and email her or her contact her to tell her that she might need to have the physician look for spasms! Not that I am wishing anything bad on her....Just concerned. Had anybody else wondered this?

Nikki




| Recommend | Alert   Current page

Replies to this message

Re: Ashley Simpson....SD???
Re: Ashley Simpson....SD??? -- Nikki Top of thread Archive
Posted by: Lynne Martinez ®
02/02/2005, 18:09:10


Nikki,

SD is the most rare and severe vocal disorder, and is the only vocal disorder which is neurological.

Just because someone sounds bad (sometimes really bad) doesn't mean they have SD.

A professional singer is much more likely to have many functional vocal conditions related to the high demands on their larynx. Such as nodes or MTD or a number of other things which are not neurological.

Mid-way through my research (15 years worth) to discover what was wrong with my voice, I encountered information which, bottom-line, said, "every larynx has its limit."

Vocal performers often stress their laryngeal-instrument WAY beyond what their bodies can handle. For professional performers, high-quality vocal training is an absolute necessity in order to preserve the vocal instrument.

For the rest of us, who had to talk 10 hours a day to do our jobs, the voice is absolutely necessary but (believe it or not) not as stressful to the larynx as being a professional performer at the Met, or wherever.

The greatest singers have a very strong and powerful vocal instrument. The best ones are born with a strong laryngeal instrument, and learn how to use it properly with training. The rest of us don't, even though some of the folks with less powerful larynx's sing also, even though they don't sound like a Metropolitan Opera Star.

Also, keep in mind that many people posting on this BB do not have SD. SD is in the "rare and severe" category of vocal disorders (even though SD itself runs the gamut from mild to very severe).

Just because a voice sounds really bad does not mean it's a neurological laryngeal vocal disorder. Spasmodic Dysphonia. We are rare --- and special.

--Lynne (AD-SD; RLN; PVFM; Northern California)




| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: Ashley Simpson....SD???
Re: Re: Ashley Simpson....SD??? -- Lynne Martinez Top of thread Archive
Posted by: Nikki ®
02/02/2005, 22:39:39


Lynne,

I refer to SD as "unpopular medical condition" and you refer to it as rare. But is it really rare or is that a lot of people just don't know they have it? That's another topic. I'm just really still confused about this "neurological" disorder. No one in my family has anything even remotely similar to this condition and the only thing in my past that relates to my voice is the fact that I have been singing since I was a child. And I'm not talking about "shower singing" or "audience" singing but rather performing for an audience for at least 20 years. I never had vocal training so I know I was hard on my voice and pushed it to the limit all the time. And I also have a job that requires you to speak 80% of the time. I was never a sickly person, i.e. cold, flu, upper respiratory infections. That's another topic. Point is, this was the only reason I felt that Ashley Simpson could have SD, is because we have similar backgrounds. Before the SD fully kicked in, my voice was good sometimes and bad sometimes, just like hers. And as I mentioned before, she too was diagnosed with acid reflux, which is the first diagnosis for a lot of SD'ers. And I was also diagnosed with MTD, but when it was all said and done, SD was my true diagnosis. And I am one of those people whose voice 'sounded bad' and I did have SD. I think a lot of us SD'ers pay more attention to other peoples voices, especially when it's raspy...now that we know what we have. It almost becomes second nature. I wish I could save the world, but I can't. Maybe if more people paid attention to their bad sounding voice, there would be a smaller percentage of people going 3-10 years not knowing their true diagnosis. But I do hear what you are saying.

Nikki



Modified by Nikki at Wed, Feb 02, 2005, 22:42:42

| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: Ashley Simpson....SD???
Re: Ashley Simpson....SD??? -- Nikki Top of thread Archive
Posted by: Mandy ®
02/02/2005, 21:04:53


Nikki, I watched Ashley's show the other night and wondered the same thing. Knowing many go undiagnosed or misdiagnosed for so long, makes me also wonder how many people have this and do not know it. I do understand what the first person who replyed to this said. I understand you were just wondering, I do to. Mandy



| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: Ashley Simpson....SD???
Re: Ashley Simpson....SD??? -- Nikki Top of thread Archive
Posted by: Jeannee ®
02/03/2005, 08:31:31


I saw the show where she had he throat scoped and was told acid reflux. Of course that's what I keep being told and it made me mad for her! This was before her first live performance and they were worried her voice would not be rested for the show. It's very interesting to me. When she was on 7th Heaven her voice at times was raspy also.
Jeannee.



| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: Ashley Simpson....SD???
Re: Ashley Simpson....SD??? -- Nikki Top of thread Archive
Posted by: charlyn ®
02/03/2005, 18:25:44


When I first heard of the voice problems with Acid Reflux as the excuse I thought poor girl I wonder if she is headed for SD. I guess she would have access to a good throat Dr...

I just know that I had problems after FINALLY being diagnosed when I saw the Family Practice Dr...I had developed a cough...so she started trying to prescribe Acid Reflux medication....I let her know that I knew that the Blood Pressure Medication I was on could cause coughing...That I had had acid problems in the past and I really didn't feel that I was having that type of problem....She changed the Blood Pressure medicine and the cough was gone...Without taking Acid Reflux Medication.

I later mentioned the problem to the Speech Therapist and she commented that Acid Relux would with the vocal cords would show up on the STROBE SCOPE...However I had seen another ENT DR about 10 years before this, and he used a scope thing down the nose and failed to diagnose the problem....SO perhaps it depends on the DR or the TYPE of scope....




| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page